Best Health Insurance in 2024 for Toledo, Ohio

  • Find out what health insurance costs in Toledo, Ohio
  • Check out our health insurance plan top picks
  • Learn why small businesses are paying attention to the health insurance marketplace

Note: These are StretchDollar recommendations. For complex health questions, best to check with a broker.

How to find affordable health insurance (for you and your small business employees)

The marketplace, also known as a health insurance exchange, allows individuals and families to shop for health insurance. Established by the federal government, it mandates that listed health plans provide comprehensive benefits.

In 2019, the government introduced ICHRA (Individual Health Reimbursement Arrangement), a unique way for small businesses to offer health benefits. Through ICHRA, business owners can give pre-tax money to employees for purchasing their own health plans from the marketplace. More employees than ever before are shopping the marketplace. Let's explore the options.

Best health plans in Toledo — StretchDollar’s picks

Good news if you live in Toledo, Ohio — there are plenty of health insurance options to choose from. We’ve selected some of the best health plans based on cost and network.

Best if you like telemedicine + $0 deductibles.

Aetna Bronze 4 + $0 deductible

Best health plan if you need ProMedica in network.

Ambetter Elite Bronze

Best general all-around option for the price and network.

Ambetter Everyday Gold

Lowest-cost plans (worth the money) in Toledo

If you're keeping an eye on your budget, check out these budget-friendly health insurance options in Toledo, Ohio.

Plan Name
Monthly Premium*
Carrier
Marketplace Bronze First
$345
CareSource
Aetna Bronze 4 + $0 deductible
$368
Aetna CVSHealth
Expanded Bronze Standard 1
$383
Paramount

*Based on 30-year-old male

Best mental health coverage in Toledo

If having solid mental health support matters to you, these health insurance plans have you covered.

Plan Name
Monthly Premium*
Carrier
Bronze 4
$15 copay
Aetna CVSHealth
Standard Expanded Bronze
$20 copay
Ambetter
Marketplace Bronze First
$50 copay
CareSource

Note: If you have a particular therapist you love (and we hope you do), we recommend double checking with them that they accept these plans before purchasing one.

Carriers in Toledo that take credit cards

Looking to rack up some credit card rewards by paying your health insurance premiums? Good news! These health insurance providers in Toledo, Ohio, allow you to pay with a credit card:

  • Aetna CVSHealth
  • Ambetter from Buckeye Health Plan
  • Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield
  • CareSource
  • MedMutual
  • Molina Marketplace
  • *Paramount Insurance Company
  • UnitedHealthcare

*Credit card permitted for premiums <$10,000

Favorite perks — StretchDollar’s picks

Here are a few health insurance plans in Toledo, Ohio that throw in some extra perks:

Perk
Carrier
CareSource

Free access to popular fitness centers/gyms

Insurance carriers in Toledo, Ohio

Shopping for health insurance on the Toledo, Ohio marketplace offers you plenty of options. In Toledo, you'll find over 110 plans from eight different health insurance carriers.

  • Aetna CVS Health
  • Ambetter from Buckeye Health Plan
  • Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield
  • CareSource
  • MedMutual
  • Molina Marketplace
  • Paramount Insurance Company
  • UnitedHealthcare

Understanding health insurance

Health insurance has a lot of terms and jargon that are important to know. Here’s some of the main ones you’ll come across. You can find more here.

EPO
POS
Deductible
Out-of-pocket max

When to get help finding a health plan

Seeing out-of-network doctors or taking medicines that aren’t covered by your health plan can become quite costly. If you have complicated health needs or take specialty medicines, you should consult a broker to make sure your doctors and prescriptions are covered.

Why more small businesses are choosing ICHRAs

Health insurance is complicated and costly, especially for small businesses. High participation rates and contribution requirements make it out of reach for many. Not to mention, traditional group health insurance plans often require 60+ hours of administrative work. That’s where ICHRA comes in. Small business owners finally can control their benefits budget and setup takes just ten minutes. Learn more.

StretchDollar’s guide to the best small business health insurance in Ohio. Learn more about employee health coverage options for SMBs and startups with this guide.

Learn more

FAQ

What is the cheapest health plan in Toledo, Ohio?
What types of health plans are available in Toledo, Ohio?
Are there any PPO health plans in Toledo, Ohio?
How do premium tax credits work?

Want to start shopping?

Get started